Bread Box Bakery & Café

120 N Morton St Shipshewana

Contact Information

"Scratch Baking Since 1984" The Bread Box Bakery and Cafe is located in the Heart of Shipshewana, Indiana and has been serving Scratch-baked traditional foods since! Our mission has always been to offer a unique dining experience to each customer.

We offers 11 kinds of breads, saucer-sized cookies, flaky crust pies, giant cinnamon rolls, cakes and many varieties of mouth-watering desserts. From personal sized pies to the secret recipe peanut brittle chewies, there is aways something for everyone. The Bread Box Bakery and Cafe also carries other locally produced items such as Yoder's popcorn, Fern's Noodles and our homemade jams, jellies and butters.

Lunch is served at the Cafe where you can choose from the many types of sandwiches or paninis served on homemade bread. Try a fresh salad or a bowl of soup made from scratch. Enjoy outdoor dining in our garden setting.

Most of the delicious items from the Bread Box Bakery & Cafe can also be purchased at the Shipshewana Flea Market Tuesdays and Wednesdays May through September, is located just two blocks from the store.

  • Group Friendly
  • Bakery
  • Deli
  • Credit Cards Accepted
  • Free WiFi
  • Gift Certificates Available
  • Handicap Accessible
  • Outdoor Dining
  • Take Out
  • Downtown Shipshewana
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating
Based on 95 reviews | Write a review

Yummy baked goods

5 Reviewed 09-18-17

Wonderful selection of delicious baked goods. We bought the pumpkin cake with walnut frosting, cinnamon raisin bread, Amish jams and peanut butter spread. Very reasonable pricing and quality bakery... Read More

Huge selection of fresh made food

5 Reviewed 08-20-17

I stopped in for a quick lunch and chose a wrap. It came with a pickle and potato chips. Service was very quick. There is a huge menu of fresh made food and they have a large bakery FULL of Amish... Read More

Very Nice Bakery

5 Reviewed 08-11-17

We managed to get into the bakery as we were getting ready to leave to return home. We purchased some homemade Amish breads and had to take a cinnamon roll for the trip. Both were excellent. Read More

Explore Nearby

On the map below, you'll find Bread Box Bakery & Café, as well as a few of the lodging, dining, and activities that are close by.


Related Listings by Category

Get your official copy of our

Destination Guide

Request Printed Guide

View E-Guide

Stay informed and sign up for the

Shipshe E-Newsletter

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.