East of Chicago Pizza

350 S Van Buren St Shipshewana

Contact Information

Open on Sundays
Enjoy our lunch and dinner buffet with pizza, subs, salad bar and more! Conveniently located across from the Flea Market, offering Family-friendly prices.

Try our signature pan crust, ligt and airy with a crunch or one of our fresh over-baked subs. For dessert, try one of our delicious dessert pizzas.

Deliver and carry-out also available.

Hours: Monday-Thursday 11am-9pm | Friday-Saturday 11am-11pm | Sunday 11am-9pm

  • Delivery Available
  • Group Friendly
  • Credit Cards Accepted
  • Free WiFi
  • Handicap Accessible
  • Take Out
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating
Based on 97 reviews | Write a review

First night great service, second night horrible experience!

3 Reviewed 11-12-18

We got into town later Thursday night & since it was the only restaurant open we popped in around 7:30. We had a young lady take our order and treated us GREAT! Our pizzas were steaming hot and came... Read More

Pizza buffet!

4 Reviewed 10-31-18

My first visit to a East of Chicago Pizza restaurant. The food was good and this is a place I would recommend. Read More


5 Reviewed 10-23-18

Stopped in while shopping at the Davis Mercantile to try these pretzels that everyone had given great reviews on the website. Was very busy and had to wait about 10 mins for our order the pretzels... Read More

Explore Nearby

On the map below, you'll find East of Chicago Pizza, as well as a few of the lodging, dining, and activities that are close by.


Related Listings by Category

Get your official copy of our

Destination Guide

Request Printed Guide

View E-Guide

Stay informed and sign up for the


Sign Up