Fireside Cafe is a cozy casual restaurant featuring in-house slow-smoked meats and beans and a variety of made-from-scratch recipes for breakfast, lunch, dinner, & dessert. We also offer super-premium ice cream, locally roasted coffee, housemade fudge, and more.
Place your order at the counter, then have a seat in the beautiful, spacious dining room, and we'll bring the food to your table.
Located inside Yoder's Shopping Center, or order in Shipshewana's first drive-thru, which is car, buggy, bicycle, and tractor-friendly!
- Delivery Available
- Group Friendly
- Banquet Facility
- Credit Cards Accepted
- Free WiFi
- Gift Certificates Available
- Handicap Accessible
- Take Out
- Downtown Shipshewana
Good food, good serviceReviewed 10-30-17
Nice place to grab lunch. You order your food and pay and then have a seat and they bring it to you. Their pulled pork was good, but their BBQ sauce was watered down and runny. They have excellent... Read More
Delicious foodReviewed 10-12-17
Each person in our party chose something different from the menu. One had a salad and it was declared fresh and tasty. One had a burger. The meat was wonderful. Read More
Great placeReviewed 10-11-17
We traveled with a group and ate here. They were very accommadating to us. The food came out quickly. Their ice cream is a specialty and should be tried! The broccoli salad was excellent. The... Read More
On the map below, you'll find Fireside Cafe, as well as a few of the lodging, dining, and activities that are close by.