Open After 5pm in Amish Country

When the sun begins to set, Amish Country takes on a whole new charm. Spend your evenings enjoying live entertainment, savoring delicious local flavors, sipping craft cocktails, browsing unique shops, or relaxing under the stars after a full day of exploring. From cozy date nights to laid-back evenings with friends, Amish Country after 5 offers the perfect mix of small-town charm and memorable nighttime experiences.

Shipshewana 

 

  • Blue Gate Restaurant - Local favorite for Amish homestyle cooking. Offering all you can eat buffet or menu dining there is something for everyone. 
  • East of Chicago Pizza - Salad Bar and pizza buffet with speciality pizzas for lunch and dinner. 
  • Danny's Diner Shipshewana - Enjoy all the different options from buffet or order from a menu. We have a variety of appetizers, salads, wraps, and hoagies.
  • Wana Cup Restaurant - Quaint local establishment featuring hearty American platters, plus homemade root beer & ice cream.

Around the Neighborhood

Looking for something other than traditional Amish homestyle cooking? Just a short drive from downtown Shipshewana, the town of LaGrange offers a relaxed casual dining scene filled with flavorful eats, sweet treats, and local favorites. From handcrafted burgers, BBQ, and pizza to gourmet desserts, fresh pastries, and creamy ice cream, you’ll find plenty of delicious options to satisfy every craving.

  • Destination 814 - Scratch Kitchen with daily features and an incredible menu. Handcrafted burgers & sandwiches, chicken, salmon, & steak entrees. One of a kind bar selection with 14 domestic & craft taps, 250+ whiskies, and many craft cocktails. 
  • Fireside Craft Burgers & Brews - Handcrafted burgers, house-smoked meats, 20+ craft draft beers and signature cocktails. Family-friendly restaurant with takeout & catering available.
  • Linder's Tavern on Main - Family owned restaurant featuring cheesy pizza, fresh fried fish, hand tossed salads, or in house smoked meats. Full bar focused on Indiana based craft brew and Indiana distilled liquor.
  • Howies Six Mile  Restaurant - Popular casual restaurant featuring Amish-made dishes, such as breakfast haystacks.
  • Legendary Slices - Casual restaurant dishing up hand-tossed pies with a variety of toppings, plus bread sticks and cheesecakes.
  • Lucy's Vedie Twist - Enjoy delightful array of ice cream flavors and soft serve creations that cater to every sweet tooth.
  • Sizzle Family Dining - Serving breakfast, lunch & dinner in the heart of LaGrange, IN. Family-friendly, fresh meals, and a warm atmosphere.
  • Turkey Lake Restaurant & Tavern - Hearty fish dinners and legendary homemade tartar sauce, we pride ourselves on generous portions that delight both locals and tourists.
  • Coody Brown's Lakeside Grill, Wolcottville - Casual waterside eatery featuring fried bluegill burgers, tacos, and prime rib, plus an outdoor deck for dining and fish feeding.

Other Choices

  • Backroads Tavern in Wolcottville - Comfort food, specialty cocktails, and beer served in a casual setting.
  • The Hilltop Restaurant, Middlebury - Laid-back eatery showcasing old-time favorites and local dishes, plus friendly service
  • South Side Soda Shop, Goshen - Restored diner with dining car & a 1940s soda fountain serves classic American eats, shakes & malts.
  • West on Warren, Middlebury - Relaxed eatery serving burgers and steak, along with beer and cocktails.

Fast Food Options

 

  • Dairy Queen, Middlebury
  • Jimmy John's, Middlebury
  • McDonalds, LaGrange
  • Piza hut, LaGrange
  • Taco Bell, Middlebury