There’s something about coffee in Shipshewana that just hits differently. Maybe it’s the slower pace, the friendly conversations, or the way a warm cup fits perfectly into a day of shopping, exploring, and wandering Indiana’s Amish Country backroads. Whatever it is, Shipshewana and the surrounding area are full of great spots to grab a cup. From cozy cafés inside iconic buildings to small-town roasters worth the short drive, this destination takes coffee seriously.
Here’s where to find some of the best coffee stops in Shipshewana, each with its own personality and reason to visit.
Kitchen Cupboard at Davis Mercantile
A visit to Shipshewana often starts at the Davis Mercantile, and the Kitchen Cupboard is one of the best places to fuel up before a full day of exploring. Located inside the mercantile next to Jo Jo’s Pretzels, this longtime favorite has been serving visitors since 1991 and is owned by the King family. The shop uses locally roasted beans from The Refinery in Goshen, giving their coffee a rich, local flavor that regulars appreciate. One of the best perks is that Kitchen Cupboard opens at 8 a.m., before the rest of the Davis Mercantile, which makes it the perfect place to grab a cup of coffee and get a jump on shopping before the crowds arrive.
Shipshe pro tip: Take a look at the colorful mural on the wall at Jo Jo’s Pretzels next door. Manager Mariah from Kitchen Cupboard is featured in the artwork, a fun local detail that adds a little personality to your stop at the Davis Mercantile.
Koffie Haus
Koffie Haus offers a relaxed coffee experience that fits naturally into the rhythm of Shipshewana and Indiana’s Amish Country, conveniently located near E and S and Ben’s Pretzels. What truly sets Koffie Haus apart, though, is the attention given to clean ingredients. Drinks and menu items are prepared without seed oils, artificial food dyes, or unnecessary additives, reflecting owner Elizabeth Miller’s passion for simple, intentional living. For travelers and locals who care about what goes into their food and coffee, Koffie Haus has become a reliable stop for a thoughtfully crafted cup.
Shipshe Pro Tip: If you’re exploring Shipshewana early, swing through the Koffie Haus drive-through for your coffee before heading out for the day. It’s a great way to fuel up with a clean-ingredient drink before shopping at E&S Sales or browsing the shops around town.
Fawn River Coffee + Morton
Fawn River Coffee + Morton brings a modern coffee shop feel to Shipshewana while still fitting right into Indiana’s Amish Country. Located on Morton Street just behind the Davis Mercantile, it’s an easy walk if you park once and explore the area. The café is connected to the Plaid Umbrella Antique, Thrift, and Consignment Shop, making it a fun stop between browsing and shopping. Fawn River is known for its quality beans and well-crafted espresso drinks, but the menu offers plenty more. They serve the famous Diamond Donuts from LaGrange County’s Foltz Bakery along with pastries, cake balls, soups, and sandwiches. You’ll also find gluten-free and vegan pastry options, plus boba tea for anyone in your group who isn’t a coffee fan. A large community table that seats about ten people makes it a great place to gather over coffee and conversation. Locals, including Jesse from Riverwood Pottery, are known to stop in for their chai lattes. Bonus: they also have a second location in nearby LaGrange.
Shipshe Pro Tip: Park at the Davis Mercantile, shop the stores, then walk around back to Fawn River Coffee + Morton for a coffee break and a donut from Foltz Bakery.
Hoosier Banquets & Cafe at Yoder’s Shopping Center
Inside Yoder’s Shopping Center, Hoosier Banquets & Cafe serves up classic café comfort with a side of shopping fun. The coffee here is straightforward and satisfying, making it a solid stop when you’re browsing the shops or meeting up with friends for a casual break. What makes this place even more notable is that you’ll feel like you are having coffee at your grandma’s kitchen table, with the comfort food you are pairing with your sips.
Country Lane Bakery 2.0
Country Lane Bakery 2.0 understands the assignment when it comes to coffee and classic Amish Country baking. Located on Morton Street and just an easy walk from the south parking lot of the Davis Mercantile, this Amish-owned bakery has become a favorite gathering spot. Known for making their pies, breads, donuts, and other baked goods from scratch, the bakery delivers the kind of homemade flavors people travel to Amish Country to find. Pair your coffee with a fresh donut or one of their indulgent sweet treat. The bakery has even earned the title of Best Bakery two years in a row, proving it’s more than just hype. Country Lane Bakery 2.0 is also well known for its hearty chicken pot pies along with a full menu of soups, sandwiches, salads, and breakfast and lunch options. They open really early, which makes it a popular morning hangout for members of the Amish community who gather there before starting their day.
Shipshe Pro Tip: Park once at the south lot of the Davis Mercantile and walk over to Country Lane Bakery 2.0 for coffee and a donut before shopping. Just remember they’re closed on Mondays.
Shipshewana Popcorn Company
While famous for its popcorn flavors, Shipshewana Popcorn Company also offers coffee, making it a fun and unexpected stop. It’s a great place to grab a cup while sampling sweet and savory snacks, especially if you like your coffee break with a little variety.
Shipshe Pro-tip: This is a great coffee stop for those traveling with kids; there are so many ways to indulge here, from slushies to popcorn.
Five Lakes Coffee
Five Lakes Coffee is a go-to for thoughtfully brewed drinks with fair-trade coffee roasted at their roastery in Michigan. With a focus on quality and consistency, it’s a favorite for locals and visitors who want a dependable cup before heading out to explore the area. One great thing about Five Lakes Coffee is that there are a few peppered in the surrounding area if you want a coffee fix later in the day while out exploring.
Shipshe pro tip: Grab one of their breakfast sandwiches or drop into the Corn Crib, located next door, for a snack.
Red Bud Coffee & Tea
For those who like options beyond traditional coffee, Red Bud Coffee & Tea offers both coffee and tea selections that have all the feels for both kinds of drinkers. It’s a great choice if your group has mixed preferences or if you’re in the mood to switch things up. You’ll want to plan plenty of time here, as you’ll sniff and sip your way through the store.
Just beyond Shipshewana, several nearby towns offer coffee stops that are well worth adding to your route. Brickhouse Coffee is an easy drive away and a favorite for its friendly service and relaxed, welcoming atmosphere, making visitors feel like regulars from the moment they walk in. In Middlebury, Trailside Coffee Co. blends quality coffee with a strong sense of community, creating a comfortable place to pause, meet up, or linger a little longer after a walk through town. Rounding out the trio, Coffee & Cream adds a sweet touch to the coffee experience, pairing freshly brewed drinks with ice cream and desserts for a stop that feels especially indulgent and perfect for warm-weather exploring or a simple treat along the way.
From Shipshewana to Middlebury, Topeka, LaGrange, and South Milford, this corner of Indiana proves that great coffee is never far away. Each stop offers something a little different, giving coffee lovers plenty of reasons to linger and enjoy the journey one cup at a time.