It’s Foodie Friday – Carey’s Cakery & Bake Shop

It’s Foodie Friday for us at the Visitor’s Center. Every Friday we decide on a local eatery for lunch. Don’t ask me why its on Fridays… somehow it’s become a “Foodie Friday” that is highly anticipated!

This week we decided on Carey’s Cakery & Bake Shop in LaGrange. This place is a hidden gem! She has bakery cases loaded with cookies, donuts, cupcakes, basically anything you can think of that is pure deliciousness. They serve lunch too, nachos, fresh sandwiches/wraps, calzones, and pizza. The sandwich and wraps you may order as a meal, which is served with a side of chips and a fresh cookie.

We all decided on nachos!

Patti ordered the Taco Nacho Supreme. Taco meat, refried beans, onions, black olives, cheddar cheese, diced tomatoes and sour cream layered between the tortilla chips!

Beth chose the Buffalo Chicken Nacho. Chicken, buffalo sauce, onions, mozzarella cheese and sour cream.

Jordan and I went with the Chicken Fajita Nacho. Grilled Chicken, green & red peppers, onions with queso sauce and sour cream.

We were all surprised at how these nachos were layered. Every bite you took had all the good toppings with it as well! We all ordered the ½ orders and we are glad that we did. I know I wouldn’t have been able to eat an entire order.

I couldn’t pass up these adorable shamrock cookies! I have quite the sweet tooth, so dessert is almost always necessary! These really hit the spot!

Can’t wait till Next Friday… hmmmm wonder where we will eat!?!

I enjoy food & hope you enjoy these quick little blogs, I am by no means a food critic & do not proclaim to be. I wonder if I can convince the crew to order desserts for lunch…

About The Amish Culture: Six Social Courtesies

LaGrange County and Shipshewana are home to the third-largest Amish community in the nation. This community’s simple way of life is the reason many people visit our area — to observe, learn about, pay tribute to, and purchase items from the Amish. Here are a few things to remember as you travel to our area …

Read More >

Scenic Fall Drive in Shipshewana, Indiana

Typically when you roll into Shipshewana, you’re greeted by endless farms and open fields. It might be surprising to hear of the beautiful fall foliage that can be seen this time of year. The natural beauty here in LaGrange County can often be underappreciated, many people not knowing about hidden gems like the Pigeon River …

Read More >

15 Best Things to Do in Shipshewana, Indiana

This blog was originally posted on shipshewanatradingplace.com  By Anna Camburn Shipshewana brings simple living, Amish hospitality, amazing shopping, and fun activities to Northern Indiana. Take in the area’s best attractions including shopping the Midwest’s Largest Flea Market, catching a musical at the Blue Gate Theatre,  or eating a home-cooked Amish meal. (All group-friendly!) You’ll want to spend …

Read More >

Get your official copy of our

Destination Guide

Request Printed Guide

View E-Guide

Stay informed and sign up for the

EMAIL-Newsletter

Sign Up