Bakeries & Sweet Treats
Pie, Pastries & Plenty of Smiles
Treat yourself to something sweet in Shipshewana! From homemade pies and fresh donuts to hand-dipped ice cream, fudge, cinnamon rolls, and bakery favorites, Amish Country is filled with irresistible desserts and tasty treats. Whether you’re craving a classic slice of pie like grandma used to make or looking for the perfect afternoon pick-me-up, you’ll find plenty of delicious stops to satisfy your sweet tooth.
Amish Frozen Custard & Soft Serve Ice Cream
5970 N SR 5
Shipshewana
IN
46565
260-768-7770
Country Lane Bakery
59162 CR 43
Middlebury
IN
46540
574-825-7918
Country Lane Bakery 2.0
120 N Morton St
Shipshewana
IN
46565
(260)293-1255
Essenhaus Bakery
240 US Hwy 20
Middlebury
IN
46540
574-825-9471
Five Lakes Coffee
0920 N SR 5
Shipshewana
IN
46565
(260)264-7190
JoJo’s Pretzels
225 N Harrison St
Shipshewana
IN
46565
260-768-7759
Mom’s Ice Cream
655 S Van Buren St
Shipshewana
IN
46565
260-350-0479
Red Bud Gift Shop & Coffee Tea Cafe
461 S Van Buren St
Shipshewana
IN
46565
260-768-3013
Rise’n Roll Bakery & Cafe
1065 N 1150 W
Middlebury
IN
46540
574-825-4032
Shipshewana Popcorn Co.
100 S Van Buren St
Shipshewana
IN
465656
260-293-2534
South Side Soda Shop
1122 S Main St
Goshen
IN
46526
574-534-3790
Victorian Candy Company
457 S Van Buren
Shipshewana
IN
46565
260-768-3272
Yoder Popcorn
0920 N SR 5
Shipshewana
IN
46565
260-768-4051