Amish Dining
Taste Authentic Amish Homestyle Cooking
Nothing says “welcome to Amish Country” quite like a hearty homestyle meal. From crispy fried chicken and creamy mashed potatoes to homemade noodles and fresh-baked pies, dining in Shipshewana is all about comfort food made with care. Stop by Blue Gate Restaurant for classic Amish favorites, and save room for a slice of pie or a sweet treat from the bakery next door.
For a truly memorable experience, enjoy a meal inside an Amish home. These one-of-a-kind dining experiences fill quickly, so reservations should be made well in advance—ideally when booking your stay.
Looking for something lighter? Local favorites like Shipshewana Auction Restaurant and Hoosier Banquets Cafe offer delicious breakfast and lunch options including soups, sandwiches, salads, and classic comfort foods.
A Taste of Shipshewana
6995 N 900 W
Shipshewana
IN
46565
260-350-7868
Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery
195 N Van Buren St
Shipshewana
IN
46565
260-768-4725
Das Dutchman Essenhaus
240 US Highway 20
Middlebury
IN
46540
574-825-9471
Eden Meadow Banquets
1745 S 1000 W
Shipshewana
IN
46565
260-499-0150
Hoosier Banquet Coffee Shop & Cafe
300 S Van Buren St
Shipshewana
IN
46565
260-336-8533
Shipshewana Auction Restaurant
345 S Van Buren St
Shipshewana
IN
46565
(260) 336-8362
The Carriage House
5280 S 500 W
Topeka
IN
46571
260-768-8199 ext 2128
Tiffany’s Restaurant
414 E Lake St
Topeka
IN
46571
260-593-2988
Woodside Diner, LLC
1385 E 250 N
LaGrange
IN
46761
260-499-4230
Yoder’s Homestyle Cooking, LLC
10667 W 325 N
Shipshewana
IN
46565
260-768-3078