Amish Country Gift Guide
This holiday season, make gift shopping feel special again. Shipshewana’s Holiday Gift Guide brings together unique finds from local shops, makers and small businesses, all in one easy place. From handcrafted signs and locally made pottery to gourmet popcorn, jams, lavender products, meat-and-cheese boxes and sweet treats, each gift has a story behind it.
It is perfect for the people on your list who already have everything, the ones who love something homemade, and the ones who are happiest with something delicious to share. Shop the guide online, then plan a day in Shipshewana to see the storefronts, meet the makers and enjoy the slower pace of holiday shopping in Amish Country. Along the way, discover decorated shops, cozy treats and plenty of small-town Christmas charm.
Whether you shop online or spend the day in town, Shipshewana makes it easy to find gifts with meaning, flavor and holiday charm.
Bloomfield Schoolhouse Lavender
Selfie-care Gift Set
Soft, soothing and beautifully giftable, this lavender self-care set from Bloomfield Schoolhouse Lavender brings a little calm to the holiday season. Featuring products like Lavender Mist, Silk Peptide Face Lotion, Botanical Glow Face Serum and a Milk and Collagen Face Bar, this collection feels thoughtful, elegant and personal. It is a lovely gift for anyone who could use a quiet moment of relaxation during the busiest time of year.
How to Buy: Shop online or visit Bloomfield Schoolhouse Lavender.
Coblentz Chocolate Company
Deluxe Assortment
Give the gift of rich, handcrafted chocolate with Coblentz Chocolate Company’s Deluxe Assortment. Beautifully boxed and filled with a tempting variety of our finest chocolates, it’s a classic holiday gift sure to delight chocolate lovers. From creamy caramels to irresistible nut and chocolate favorites, there’s something for everyone to enjoy.
How to Buy: Shop online or visit Coblentz Chocolate Company.
Jo Jo's Pretzels
Sweet Mustard Gift Box
Give the gift of a perfect pair with Jo Jo’s Hot Mustard and Sweet Mustard, boxed together and ready for holiday snacking. This flavorful duo is made for pretzels, sandwiches, snack boards and festive gatherings, and it includes a Jo Jo’s token good for one free pretzel. It is a fun, delicious Shipshewana gift that gives them something to enjoy now and a reason to stop back in later.
How to Buy: Shop online or visit Jo Jo’s Pretzels.
Joyfully Said
Goodness of God Sign
This 24x12 handcrafted sign from Joyfully Said is a beautiful way to bring meaningful décor into the home. Made in their workshop, the piece features raised wood lettering that is lasered in-house and thoughtfully finished for a warm, timeless look. With words that serve as a visual reminder of God’s faithfulness, this best-selling sign makes a heartfelt holiday gift for anyone who loves faith-inspired home décor.
How to buy: Shop online or visit Joyfully Said in Middlebury.
Riverwood Pottery
Handcrafted Holiday Pottery
Festive, functional and full of charm, Riverwood Pottery’s handcrafted holiday pieces make beautiful gifts for the season. From cozy Christmas mugs to decorative accents and one-of-a-kind pottery, each piece brings a locally made touch to holiday gifting. These cheerful finds are perfect for coffee lovers, collectors, teachers, hosts or anyone who appreciates something made by hand.
How to Buy: Shop online or visit Riverwood Pottery on Morton Street.
Scherger's Kettle
Christmas Jammies Gift Box
Sweet, simple and full of Amish Country flavor, the Christmas Jammies Gift Box from Scherger’s Kettle is a charming holiday treat for anyone who loves homemade-style jams and jellies. Filled with festive favorites like Christmas Jam, Peach Jam, Blackberry Jam, Raspberry Jam, Triple Berry Jam and Dandelion Jelly, this gift box brings a taste of Shipshewana to the breakfast table long after Christmas morning.
How to Buy: Shop online or visit Scherger’s Kettle.
Shipshewana-Opoly
Bring game night home with a Shipshewana twist. Shipshewana-Opoly is a locally inspired board game filled with familiar places, small-town charm, and nods to the community visitors love. It makes a fun, family-friendly gift for anyone who wants to remember their trip, celebrate their favorite town, or add a little Amish Country fun to the holidays.
How to Buy: Visit Shipshewana Visitor’s Center - 350 S Van Buren St, Shipshewana.
Shipshewana Popcorn Company
Merry & Popped Popcorn Sampler
The Merry & Popped Popcorn Sampler from Shipshewana Popcorn Company is a fun, festive gift for movie nights, stocking stuffers, teacher gifts and snack lovers of every kind. Featuring a cheerful mix of sweet, salty and seasonal popcorn flavors, this gift box is easy to share and even easier to love. It is a playful way to wrap up a little Shipshewana crunch for the holidays.
How to Buy: Shop online or visit Shipshewana Popcorn Company
Yoder Popcorn
Movie Night Bucket
Make movie night extra fun with this nostalgic popcorn gift bucket from Yoder Popcorn. Packed with 3 pounds of Premium Yellow Popcorn, 3 pounds of Premium White Popcorn, butter-flavored canola oil, buttery topping, butter salt, yellow cheddar seasoning, Popcorn Jelly Bellys and butter popcorn taffy, this bucket has everything a popcorn lover needs for a cozy night in. It is a playful, ready-to-gift pick for families, snack lovers, teachers, neighbors or anyone who believes the best part of movie night is the popcorn.
How to Buy: Shop online or visit Yoder Popcorn.
Yoder's Meat & Cheese
Holiday Meat & Cheese Gift Box
Packed with savory favorites, sweet treats and classic Shipshewana flavor, the Holiday Meat & Cheese Gift Box from Yoder’s Meat & Cheese is made for sharing. With cheeses, meats, jams, snacks and candies beautifully arranged for gifting, this box is a ready-made choice for hosts, families, coworkers or anyone who loves a good holiday spread. It is the kind of gift that belongs right in the middle of the table.
How to Buy: Call 260-768-4715 to order or visit Yoder’s Meat & Cheese