12 Stocking Stuffer Ideas

Filling stockings is always a fun part of the holidays. Whether they’re full of candy, chocolates, or gift cards, you don’t have to look far to fill them to the brim. Shipshewana has plenty of shops to ensure your loved ones’ stockings are hung by the chimney with care and each one is overflowing with treats!

Here are 12 stocking stuffer ideas you’ll find in Shipshewana!

1. Grab Carhartt accessories from Parker’s Outlet
2. Kitchenware and tools from Yoder’s Shipshewana Hardware
3. Shipshe mugs, magnets, shirts and stickers at Shipshewana Craft Barn
4. Meats, cheeses, baking goods, seasonings from either E&S Sales or Yoder’s Meat & Cheese
5. Keychains, puzzles, and wooden crosses from Teaberry Wood Products
6. Candies, chocolate, and fudge from Aunt Millie’s Candy & Nuts or Victorian Candy Company
7. Individual flavors of popcorn from Shipshewana Popcorn Company or Yoder Popcorn
8. Wallets, keychains, and notebooks at Silver Star Leather
9. Books or daily inspirational quotes from GLOW – A Christian Bookstore or Light of Grace
10. Find all your quilting needs, thousands of fabric bolts, and patters at Yoder’s Department Store or Lolly’s Fabrics
11. Lavender-scented body wash, lip balm, tea, and candles from Bloomfield Schoolhouse Lavender
12. Make and bake your own pretzel or cinnamon rolls with a complete kit from Ben’s Pretzels

Add a gift card so they can get exactly what they want.

• Blue Gate Hospitality – Shop for food, concerts, clothes, and home decor at any store with the Blue Gate name!
  • Blue Gate Restaurant
  • Blue Gate Theatre
  • Blue Gate Bakery
  • Blue Gate Carriage
  • Shipshewana Furniture Co.
  • Shipshewana Craft Barn
  • Blue Gate Garden Inn
• Shipshewana Trading Place – Don’t worry about what to get them, let them pick out a treasure at an auction or book a getaway in town!
  • Farmstead Inn & Conference Center
  • Antique Auction
  • Livestock Auction
  • Shipshewana Auction Restaurant
  • Horse Auction
  • Shipshewana RV Park & Service Center
• Ben’s Pretzels – Great for grabbing a snack like Pepperoni and Cheese Bites, a traditional soft pretzel, or a pretzel dog.
• Das Dutchman Essenhaus – Stock up on monster cookies, sugar cookies, and sweet treats!

With so many wonderful options, you’re sure to find the perfect stocking stuffers for everyone on your list. Whether it’s a cozy hat from Parker’s Outlet Center, delicious treats from Victorian Candy Company, or a fun pretzel-making kit from Ben’s Pretzels, Shipshewana has something for everyone.

There are several shops to choose from in Shipshewana. You’re bound to find the perfect stocking stuffer for anyone in your life. Make sure to stop by the Visitors Center with questions, and we’ll be sure to point you in the right direction and hand you a coupon book as well!